Are you insured or uninsured?

You can't demand thousands of dollars upfront because someone is considered uninsured, then deny a cash discount because, with a bill-sharing service, they're insured!

You know what frosts my flakes?
Health care providers who want to have it both ways when patients use medical bill-sharing services.

This rant was suggested by a Grandpa Grumpy supporter who lives in the Midwest.

For years, he has relied on Christian Healthcare Ministries to help cover unexpected medical expenses.

It isn’t insurance. Instead, members make monthly contributions that are pooled together to help pay each other’s eligible medical bills.

In some ways, I think that’s better than traditional insurance because it works the way insurance did when I was younger. It helps cover major medical expenses rather than every trip to the doctor for a case of the sniffles.

Christian Healthcare Ministries charges a flat monthly rate per person, which they call a unit. Families pay for no more than three units regardless of family size.

Depending on the plan, that can mean paying a little over $300 per person each month rather than potentially thousands for traditional family health insurance, plus deductibles and copays.

The listener recently needed medical procedures at ProHealth and Aspirus facilities.

Christian Healthcare Ministries would cover 100% of the eligible costs, generally within 100 days and often much faster.

But, because he didn’t have traditional insurance, the medical providers demanded upfront payments equal to 50% of the procedures’ cost.

We’re talking potentially tens of thousands of dollars before anyone even touches a stethoscope.

So he asked about a cash discount traditionally offered to self-pay patients. Nope.

Because he was covered by “insurance,” the typical cash discount was not available.

Wait a minute.

When it’s time to collect money before treatment, he is considered “uninsured” and must pay tens of thousands of dollars in advance.

But, when it’s time to offer a self-pay discount, suddenly he is considered fully covered by health insurance?

That’s quite a medical miracle.

I’m Grandpa Grumpy, and health care providers can’t have it both ways.

If you’re going to treat bill-sharing members like insured patients when determining discounts, then wait for payment just like you do with insurance companies.

But if you’re going to demand thousands of dollars upfront because they’re “self-pay” patients, then give them the same self-pay discount everyone else gets.

Pick a lane.

Because the only thing worse than confusing medical billing is changing the definition of “insured” depending on which one makes the hospital more money.

Leave a Reply

If that made sense, check out my 100 Undeniable Truths of Life (you’re going to recognize a few)

If that made sense, check out my 100 Undeniable Truths of Life (you’re going to recognize a few)

Share the Post:

Related Posts